Our writer gets on the tools to find out.

Our writer gets on the tools to find out.
or signup to continue reading
There have been occasions in recent times when I have needed a mid-range hotel room - one in Melbourne, another in Nottingham in the UK, and a high-end room in Athens, Greece. With a raft of booking options to choose from, I was curious to discover which one would deliver the cheapest result.
The answer deeply surprised me.
On the day I needed to stay in the Adina Apartment Hotel Pentridge Melbourne, the "public rate" for the cheapest double room was $234.
If I booked through the hotel's own website, the cheapest price was an "eClub member rate" of $161.58, and this was advertised as the "guaranteed best rate".
But the same room was bookable through Qantas Hotels as a Frequent Flyer "member deal" for only $151.
A hotel can truthfully advertise a "guaranteed best rate" even when a cheaper rate is available elsewhere because booking conditions differ.
In this case, the difference was that the Qantas Hotels deal was non-refundable, whereas I could cancel a direct booking the day before arrival.
And the Qantas deal included frequent flyer points, whereas the hotel itself offered a complimentary reward of the guest's choice. When I joined the loyalty scheme and made a dummy booking, this turned out to be either a late checkout, an early check-in, or a bottle of wine.
Booked through the Agoda app on my iPhone, with an Agodasale discount and another "special discount" (which I always seem to get), the same room at the Adina was only $136. Bizarrely, however, the rate on Agoda's website was $180. On the Virgin Australia website, which is powered by Agoda, the rate was $165 including frequent flyer points.
Go figure.
Some of the more obscure websites that turned up on a Google search were ghost businesses that simply directed me back to better-known providers. No website could beat the Agoda app, even without the discounts.
In Nottingham, I chose the Mercure Nottingham City Centre George Hotel. The public rate was $154. Booked direct through Accor's ALL app, it cost $138. Qantas Hotels offered it for $138, too. Both rates included points, but both were non-refundable. The Agoda app had it for $130. American Express offered $130 too.
When I searched Skyscanner.com, which gathers prices from many different consolidators, the featured rate was $137 through Trip.com - even though the Skyscanner search also found the cheaper Agoda rate. Skyscanner obviously operates its own (commission-driven) ranking system.
I didn't know that.
Finally, I looked at the InterContinental Athenaeum Athens. The public rate for my dates was $258 before tax. If I joined IHG Rewards Club, the room would be $243. The cheapest rate I could find was offered through Traveluro.com, which had non-refundable rooms for $191.
However, the pictures on Traveluro's website were distorted screenshots and the company charged $15 extra for "VIP service" (a customer-service phoneline).
Read more on Explore:
I just wasn't game.
Then I realised the Agoda app offered the same room for $180, refundable and with taxes included. The problem was, Agoda had only one discounted room, and I needed two.
When I tried to book a room for my kids a few hours' later, the price had gone up to $330.
So, what is the cheapest way to book a hotel? For my purposes, the Agoda app.
Pity about family ...




